Skip navigation.

Labris

Banka hrane

 
Srbija 2020

Visa Woes

Perhaps because I am a foreigner, travel restrictions have emerged as a repeated theme in my conversations with the people I meet here. I’ve heard rants about the endless visa lines. I’ve listened to complaints about the limited number of countries worldwide that allow citizens of Serbia to enter without a visa. (Interestingly, I've been told that Andorra is one of that limited number, but may as well not be as it is has no airport and is therefore no more than a landlocked, visa-free island in a sea of Schengen neighbors.) And I’ve even fielded drunken marriage proposals on the premise that I, a key to a green card, could then take the “suitor” with me when I return to the States.

But all delivered with a sense of mockery and humor, these rants left me somewhat oblivious to the degree of frustration and the feeling of stagnation that can come out of a life generally restricted to a country the size of South Carolina.

Then last week I got an email from a good friend of mine, a citizen of Serbia, who had been in France for a conference. In the email she explained that instead of coming back to Serbia as planned, she had gone to Amsterdam. She said that she had met people from England who had promised to find her a job in the UK in her professional field. They told her that within the week they would work out the details, including a visa and work papers. They also told her that instead of returning to Serbia to wait, she should go to a town near Amsterdam to stay with friends of theirs - also complete strangers. That way they could come and get her when things were arranged.

As I read I couldn’t help but think how close this sounded to the stories I had heard of women from this region who are promised jobs and better futures abroad, but arrive to find themselves at best economically dependent on their transporter and at worst virtually undocumented slaves.

As though anticipating my concerns, my friend wrote that she was okay and that she hoped the plans would go smoothly because she couldn’t see any future for herself in Serbia and didn’t know when she would ever again have a chance to leave.

The desperation of her email shocked me, as did the uncertainty of the entire situation. She had told me before on several occasions that she hoped to find a job in Western Europe or the States because she was tired of life in Serbia. But I never expected her to be so willing to trust complete strangers who offered grandiose promises of a future that was sure to be illegal at best and quite dangerous at worst.

Regardless of the true intentions of these people from England, the ease with which my friend decided to trust them reflects not only a degree of naiveté on her part, but also a systematic problem. Travel and immigration restrictions have led to large-scale illegal immigration. This trend has not only left host countries with undocumented residents but has also left the immigrants themselves completely vulnerable as their illegal status reduces the degree to which they can seek protection under the law.

Such problems stemming from restricted travel and immigration reminded me of something my father once said in regards to illegal immigration in the States. A man with a heavy streak of libertarianism, he once pondered allowed if it would not be better if immigration restrictions were completely disband world wide, allowing the world’s citizens to shop around and to chose their preferred governments and countries. According to this free market thinking, governments would be in competition, and, just as products improve when companies vie for customers, so too would countries as governments vied for citizens.

Clearly the reality of such a plan is far from plausible, but the reduction of travel restriction and visa fees for citizens of Serbia and other Western Balkan countries is not. Next month in fact, if meetings go as planned, an easement of the EU visa regime for Serbian scholars, businessmen and women, and students of all ages will go under consideration by the European Parliament.

This reduction of obstacles for scholarly and business travel favors those already well employed within Serbia itself, doing little to improve the prospects of travel for citizens whose futures seem less bright within Serbia’s borders. However, the emphasis on visa facilitation for students, including those in secondary school, gives the revisions a more egalitarian edge. Not only will travel allow young people a better understanding of Serbia’s future as an EU member state, but it will also give any dream of life abroad a sense of reality. If seen as something both attainable and not as purely idyllic as imagined, perhaps fewer young people will be so quick to suspend concerns and suspicions in hopes of a dream-like future outside of Serbia.


I don't want

2 live in GBR,USA,FRA,etc.,I just want to travel all around the world like other people:(
example:I need to decide a few month earlier where I will go to vacation,and when I decide I must wait in embassy several weeks 4 answer...That s humiliating:(


Well my darling Lucy

I would like that a lot more people from western countries become aware of situation here like you did, because western countries are those who brought us a lot of problems and put us in some way in this kind of position ( to try to find way out of here no matter how). And one thing lead to another as you conected it by yourself and at the end we have poor women working as a prostitutes, being beeten, never to see their home again or men being refuges and thieves and ending up in prisons, becoming criminals if not dead(and I'm being easy in describing)
I just got back from States and I was amazed that nobody asked me for how long am I staying there but how am I going to stay in the country for good not to mention the nmbr of girls that I met there trying to get married there and in that way put them self in terrible position.I couldn't put myself in that position because it was too sad and too humiliating although I would like to live there of course.
And maybe by coming here you realized how much you take for granted everything you have in life and people here are fending just for normal life...
yes, I know it's much easier to turn away head on the other side, have a boutiqe for bears clothes and playing golf while there somewhere in the world some girl is being raiped (forced to be a prostitute)but I think it has to be returned one way or another , there's always balance in life...


living in serbia

bladerunner i live in canada and i come to serbia all the time and i think in many ways serbia is a better country. The main problem in serbia is the government like in all countrys its corrupt but serbia is a little more than it should be. But it its getting better the problem is its taking a little more time than it should. I personally am moving to serbia and think it is a great place to live. The problem in serbia is its a little harder to get rich but thats in all countrys. The great thing about serbia is you can have a descent life but not be rich and money is evil so if you have good family and friends thats all you need. yes if the usa didnt bomb us it would be a much better place it put serbia back in time!!!!!


Visa free world

I'm afraid your father's vision of a visa-free world is currently as unviable as the vision of a global free-market.
The fact is that the greatest preachers of free-market policies (US, western market ecomomies) in areas of cheaper labour and resources are very restrictive (formally or covertly) when it comes to their own markets.

Here is an interesting reader on that:
http://www.cafod.org.uk/policy_and_analysis/public_policy_papers/trade/tjm_policy_briefing

I have a documenet about the history of trade barriers by CAFOD, which shows that all the successfull market economies of today (proponents of liberal market policy) had very restrictive policies when they were developing countries (US at begin. XX, Japan and Asian Tigers in mid XX-cent, European countries during Mercantilism).

The point is that the entire global market has to be evend out, each country has to be competitive within certain limits. Then you can liberalise trade and expect that the system will maintain itself with minimum intervention and proper rules of conduct.


Lucy,

the proposal that your friend had does sound a bit dodgy. Basically, there are 2 ways she could follow in order to obtain legal worker status in UK; in both cases her perspective employers would have to obtain Work Permit for her; the next step is for her to obtain Leave to Remain (if she is in the country) or Clearance to Entry (if she is out of the country) and I suspect that for the latter, she would have to apply from the native country (i.e. Belgrade-not sure about this though)

In the paragraph about relaxing the visa regime for Serbian nationals there was something "...scholars, students, women"; now the "women" bit I don't get; why should it be easier for women to get visas then men? I suppose I am not informed up to date :)


Gender

Frankly, I understand Lucy's comment as "businessmen & businesswomen" rather than businessmen and females :)

V.


uuups sorry ;)

my mistake :) Somehow I have managed to read "businessmen" as "students" :D:D
What a dyslexic irony....


Maximum Security Prison

That is what Serbia is for 15 years already. Imagine a sentence of 15 years!! From what I learned so far the only unarguable result of strict visa regimes imposed on Serbian citizens are deep frustration for normal people and great business opportunity for all kinds of illegal activities. Schengen visa system is particularly ridiculous. If you go through the highly humiliating procedure and finally get a visa, you only get it for a strictly limited period of time. That concept is just malicious and impossible to defend.


My dear Serbian friends,

My dear Serbian friends,

This is a terrible story and I do not want to imagine in what kind of a situation she is going to end up in. In any case, the EU will grant visa facilitation to the Western Balkans very soon. That should improve the situation, i.e. reduce the desperation as Lucy rightly pointed out.

Bladerunner,

I find it hilarious how easily you blame others for your situation. This just confirms the widely held perception that Serbs are not capable of seriously dealing with their own wrongdoings and always tend to hide behind the blame they put on others, preferably Western Europe, the US, or NATO. Wake up darling, you have followed the wrong guy. Go on and deal with it now!


...

And this is true because we all well know that US and other "evil" western countries are incapable of any wrongdoing and meddling in other countries' affairs. They would never cause an armed conflict, overthrow a government, finance terrorism, or do anything to this effect outside of their borders. They would never fabricate a story in order to justify bombing the crap out of some country and invading it. No sir. They can do no evil.

Dude, you need to wake up unless you're just trolling here. Serbs are as capable of dealing with their mistakes as anyone else. However, they are stubborn people and, with every right, they feel they've been treated unjustly. You're simply echoing the same old line that Serbs somehow need to be collectively punished like a bunch of misbehaved children. Should all Serbs somehow feel responsible for actions of a certain regime? Even those who were 5 years old at the time? Even those who fought that same regime and never voted for it? Should all Americans feel responsible for the actions of their government in Vietnam, or for exterminating native Americans? Should all Brits feel responsible for killing few hundred thousand Kikuyu of Kenya? Examples are countless.

You need to grow up and realize that the difference between genocide and war on terror lies in who's got bigger guns. Size does matter in the world and that game Serbia can't win.


Goxy mate,

Quote: "You need to grow up and realize that the difference between genocide and war on terror lies in who's got bigger guns. Size does matter in the world and that game Serbia can't win."

You're quite right, so don't start a fight you can't finish. Consequently, Serbia should have settled for a peaceful break-up of the former Yugoslavia instead of going for its forceful preservation. That was a horrendous error in judgment by Serbia's inept and autistic leadership headed by Milosevic and we paid dearly for it. Other than that, your perception of worldwide double standards is spot on but I am afraid it amounts to little more than stating the obvious. Which, in turn, is not going to help us come any closer to free travel or semi-free travel. Best regards.


colensky

Just a quick comment to your reply to bladerunner and the ILEGAL ATTACK ON SERBIA FROM THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA is dispickable and was uncalled for HMMMM YES THEY ARE DOING IT IN -------IRAQ------


Happy end

How did the story of your friend end? Still hibernated in the vicinity of rainy Amsterdam?


We have followeed the wrong guy

Covek je u pravu, a mi smo krivi sto i dalje biramo ljude koji nas vuku u proslost, od koje zapad ocekuje da se ogradimo. Znaci: podjimo od sebe! Sta treba da uradimo da bi ukinuli vize? Samo ono sto je dobro za gradjane Srbije: Saradnja sa svetom, hapsenje ratnih zlocinaca, saradnja sa susedima (Albancima sa Kosova...). Nemojte samo da se zalite, nego uradite nesto!


please

daj molim te,da li je Hrvatska ista od toga navedenog uradila kada su im ukinuli vize?Jel su Gotovina,Cermak,itd bili u Hagu?Jel im predsednik bio covek koji se nalazio na medjunarodnoj optuznici?Jel im bila demilitarizovana granica?O cemu pricamo mi?


A very good

and very observant piece Lucy. There are many desperate and gullible young people here like your friend who fall for dream-like promises first and ask questions when it's too late. Visa facilitation is still a dead letter here and I honestly hope it takes effect ASAP because travelling and getting to know the world outside these walls of isolation is one of the utmost priorities for Serbia's youth. Kind regards.


Kudos

I simply cannot believe that, while a young woman might be plummeting to hell, someone here has the ignorance to discuss what "the West" did to poor Serbia or how any highly thoughtful foreign contemplation of Serbian isolation is a step towards understanding of "the Serbian problem."


Good point Delilah

However, if that young woman is indeed plummeting to hell (and I sincerely hope she isn't), bear in mind she has herself and her naivety to blame first before you point your finger at anybody else. Also, don't forget it's the 15-year long isolation with no end beckoning that has made young people in Serbia unaware of the dangers that lie in quick-fix trips to "promised lands" and susceptible to making thoughtless and costly decisions.


Wow!

It is the 15-year-long isolation that made people unaware of such dangers, therefore she has herself to blame?


This would be an opportunity

This would be an opportunity to blame the infamous evil Western powers for her fate.


said colensky in lack of

said colensky in lack of better judgement


I think Colensky was being sarcastic

Or maybe not?


yes that was sarcasm in lack

yes that was sarcasm in lack of a better judgement. got it?


Delilah,

Yes, it's the 15-year long isolation that has made young people in Serbia unaware of the dangers because the vast majority of them have never travelled abroad.
Those doing so for the first time, yearning to make new friends, may therefore be unaware that not everyone they meet is a friend.
Yes, she has herself to blame first and foremost for not thinking twice about the helping hand or "helping hand" offered to her. If she is in trouble in the first place.
Lucy was not entirely specific about her friend's field of expertise. Hopefully, the people this young woman met do actually want to help her move to Britain and get a good job, although their instructions to wait in Amsterdam for a British visa and work permit do sound fishy to say the least. But hopefully, they told her to do so thinking she may not be able to get a visa and leave Serbia again if she returns.
And one more thing: if you really are concerned over this issue to the point of taking concrete action, stop ranting at everyone else at this blog, get off your rear end and do something about it.


Don't you think it might be

Don't you think it might be wise to let someone know that your friend is possibly in danger? Or have you already done so? This story of 'a small town near Amsterdam we'll come to take you away' sounds horrific. Who on Earth would promise such a thing unless they are either a trusted friend, or the woman had absolutely no other option than to stay with strangers near Amsterdam, none of which is the case. Did your friend let the Serbian embassy know she is in Holland? I know they are generally incompetent but right now I can't think of a better way to make sure this woman doesn't become another slave trade deal.


Lucy, sorry for hijacking

Lucy, sorry for hijacking this blog.

Groxy, again, I sense that classical victim role many Serbs seem to love so much. It is not at all about collective punishment. Fare from it. But of course there is collective responsibility. Not for the crimes, but how to deal with the history. Why no one comes out saying, yes, there was a regime here in Serbia, which has committed terrible crimes against humanity, it was wrong, we regret what happened, we have learned our lesson, we will teach this our children and try that it will not happen again? A few countries had the dignity to deal with their history that way, Germany is a good example. In stead what one hears is the “we are the victims of evil foreign powers which want to punish us collectively”-mantra. Given that, the “evil foreign powers” do not find it particularly appealing to grant Serbia entry into their clubs. Thus, the problems with visas and other stuff. Rgs.


Unresponse

Colensky,

Your posts are not something that anyone wants really to respond to, so I'm sending this "unresponse".

Quote:
This just confirms the widely held perception that Serbs are not capable of seriously dealing with their own wrongdoings and always tend to hide behind the blame they put on others, preferably Western Europe, the US, or NATO.

Sentence above proves you a bigot. I guess it's easier to nurture prejudice, than deal with it.

Quote:
yes, there was a regime here in Serbia, which has committed terrible crimes against humanity, it was wrong, we regret what happened, we have learned our lesson, we will teach this our children and try that it will not happen again?

Yes, there was a regime here in Serbia, which has allegedly committed terrible war crimes (where did you get the part "against humanity"?; read the Convention), it was more than wrong and we regret it and we will teach our children about all war crimes that happened in the past, including but not limited to: WWI, WWII and Japan, Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan, Kuwait, Turkey, Iraq, Somalia, Bosnia, Sudan (Darfur) and Kosovo. Just to make it easier for you, I admit my responsibility for every crime I committed during the wars in ex-Yugoslavia region. Note: I was 11 years old when all of that happened, couldn't vote, wasn't in the army, fought to overthrow Milosevic from 1997 through 2000, had been arrested by Milosevic's police (you've read correctly, not Serbian, but Milosevic's police forces), tortured and maltreated. Presently working with a whole bunch of people from all over the world, including Americas. :)

Lucy,

I also fear your friend's situation is quite undesirable and urge you to call and report an incident to the police.

Best of luck!


Deliah, please, do not be myopic.

I believe, Lucy did not tell us this story to ask for concrete help in this specific case, but to rather highlight the problems related to years of travel restrictions, which is of course related to Serbian foreign policy. And that is what warrants a discussion of it here.


Yes, if you read Lucy's post

Yes, if you read Lucy's post it is clear how she used this event as an example to "highlight the problems related to years of travel restrictions." But you call me "myopic" for saying that you cannot just sit and blog if you know that someone you know might be in danger? I think this is the question of ethics, colensky, not my mental distortion. And I did not call for class action but was simply alarmed that this is happening in spite of other people knowing that it is as dodgy as hell.
By and by, please notice that I am not attacking Lucy nor I see any purpose in doing so.


Sorry, but a blog is not

Sorry, but a blog is not exactly 911. For clarification, myopic is not exactly a mental disorder, but simply shortsightedness, i.e. when you can not see the forest because of the trees. I was far from trying to insult you, but apparently 15 years of isolation has taken its toll on some.


Dear colensky, I know what

Dear colensky, I know what you were saying. "Mental disorder" was a play with words as myopic is also a medical term relating to a visual disorder. So when I said mental disorder I didn't mean to say you were insulting me. Also, I haven't lived in Serbia for a looong time and am not isolated at all.
I suggest you retake your high school Logic class.
Ciao


Sorry deliah, I was

Sorry deliah, I was sarcastically again. I know very well that this isolation story is a bid overblown. Serbs can and do travel abroad, maybe not as much as they would like, but they do get around. So I do not buy into this 15-years prison story and was trying pock fun of it.


Please...

Try to keep the tone calm and civil in these comments. I don't like having to delete comments that cross the line, but I am responsible for my postings and the comments that follow. I hate being put in the position of having a remove the idea behind a comment because the language itself is too heated.


Oh yeah

I forgot how "nice and pure" you are (I mean Americans). You don't do it.
Well you should have more "stomach" and hear what you are doing.
I mean don't get me wrong, nothing personnal, just I don't like hypocrites.